I've found this stuff works pretty well. It doesn't seem to last quite as long as something like ID before you need to get more (it tends to get squeezed between the fingers and away from the palm), but it does have a certain thickness or viscosity to the stuff that can provide for a very enjoyable feel. Assuming it's water-based it does clean up fairly well, too, but it can leave the skin of both your hand and penis feeling oddly soft, something that may bother some guys.